Former Army Chief Naravane Breaks Silence On Unpublished Book, Shares Penguin Statement

The controversy centres on Naravane’s autobiography Four Stars of Destiny. Publisher Penguin Random House India stated clearly that the book has not yet been published. The company said no printed or digital copies have been released. According to the publisher, the book is still in the pre-publication stage. Penguin warned that any version circulating in public would be illegal. The statement ruled out authorised sales or distribution. The publisher also stressed that only pre-orders were listed earlier. Publication, it said, happens only when retail sales begin.

Why Did The Issue Reach Parliament?

The issue escalated after Congress leader Rahul Gandhi referred to the book during the Budget Session of Parliament. He quoted portions of the book while attacking the government. His remarks triggered sharp reactions in the House. Rahul Gandhi claimed the book contained uncomfortable truths. He questioned whether the publisher or the former Army chief was misleading the public. He said he trusted the former Army chief more. The references led to repeated disruptions in Parliament.

What Did Penguin Say In Its Clarification?

Penguin issued a second clarification to address confusion. The publisher explained that announcing a book, opening pre-orders, and publishing a book are different stages. It said Four Stars of Destiny has not reached the publication stage. Penguin confirmed it holds exclusive publishing rights. The company said no copy was printed, distributed, or sold. Any material circulating online or offline was termed unauthorised. Penguin warned of legal action for copyright violations. It also urged media platforms to verify claims.

How Did Naravane Respond Personally?

General Naravane shared the publisher’s official statement on social media. This was seen as his first direct response to the controversy. He clarified that his role was limited to writing the manuscript. According to him, publication approvals lie with the publisher and authorities. He did not comment on political claims made in Parliament. His post aimed to end speculation. Sources say he wants the issue handled legally. He has avoided making political statements.

Where Did The Alleged Copy Come From?

The biggest unanswered question is how Rahul Gandhi accessed a physical copy. Some reports claimed a few copies reached bookstores. Penguin firmly denied these claims. The publisher said no authorised copies exist anywhere. Investigators are examining whether leaked manuscripts were circulated. The matter has raised concerns about data security. Officials are checking possible internal leaks. No clear source has been confirmed yet.

Police And Legal Action Underway

Delhi Police has registered an FIR regarding the circulation of the manuscript. The case involves suspected copyright infringement. Police are also examining whether sensitive information was leaked. The book had not received final clearance from the Defence Ministry. Authorities are analysing social media posts linked to the manuscript. Legal teams are coordinating with the publisher. Further action is expected after investigation.

Why The Row Has Turned Political

The controversy has taken a political turn in Parliament. The opposition is demanding transparency about the book’s contents. The government maintains that the book does not officially exist yet. Ministers have accused the opposition of misleading the House. The issue has added to ongoing parliamentary disruptions. Analysts say the case highlights gaps between politics and publishing processes. The debate is likely to continue as investigations proceed.